h1

Is Salmond’s referendum question biased & unfair?

January 27th, 2012

Does the boss of ICM have a point?

Alex Salmond announced on Wednesday that his “straightforward” question for the Scottish referendum was: “Do you agree that Scotland should be an independent country?

This has now been scrutinized by academic and polling experts who are saying that it is leading and suggest that it is designed to get a particular outcome.

According to the Telegraph the boss of ICM, Martin Boon, said the question was simple but added that his company would “refuse” to ask it as it stands.

“This is cheeky really – it suggests that ‘we all agree, don’t you?’ In short, if this were asked in the context of an opinion poll, I would expect to receive some condemnation for it being deemed as imbalanced, loaded and unfair

It’s suggested Salmond’s wording had obviously been the subject of extensive SNP polling to register the most favourable possible result.

Also quoted is Prof John Curtice, who said: “It would have been fairer to ask ‘should Scotland become independent’ rather than ‘do you agree’. In everyday conversation people are inclined to say they agree than don’t agree.”

This one will run.

Mike Smithson @MikeSmithsonOGH




  • tim

    Incorrect.

    Cameron threatened to veto a seven figure bonus.

    And Fallon is now on the radio saying the govt directly intervened to reduce the bonus.

  • MrsB

    Personally, I don’t think Blair or Brown had the “progressive mantle” so how Cameron could inherit it from them?

  • antifrank

    Mitt Romney’s price for being the Republican nominee is now 1.19 on Betfair.  On that basis, the 2.58 for him being next President looks good value.

  • Anonymous

    It is depressing that, in a country that is steeped in history, has contributed so much in the field of literature, art, science, technology, industry, political theory, sport, design, philosophy, language, film and music – amongst other things – the two things we appear to be focussing on are:

    1) The NHS
    2) Being green and reclaiming our land from the ravages of evil, evil industrialisation

    … Still, at least it looks like there’s *some* Shakespeare in it. Which is nice. And I’ll reserve some judgment. Maybe the NHS will be a minor segment while something else is going on – and hopefully the cameras will focus on that so that all the foreigners around the world aren’t sitting in their living rooms bemused as to why some nurses are prancing around the field.

  • Richard Nabavi

    I think Cameron was, unwisely, being rather economical with the truth there.  This article explains it better than most:

    http://www.heraldscotland.com/mobile/politics/political-news/cameron-pressure-on-rbs-to-cut-chiefs-bonus-in-half.1327028837

    While he too made clear no decisions had been taken on bonus payments at the 82% state-owned bank, he stressed Mr Hester would get significantly less than the £2m he received last year.
    “I can tell you something,” the PM said, “if there is a bonus, it will be a lot less than it was last year.”

    Mr Cameron also insisted that cash bonuses at RBS would once again be limited to just £2000.

    However, an RBS spokesman said the UK Government, while the major shareholder, had no direct power to veto any bonus the bank’s board approved for Mr Hester; the only power it had was political pressure.

    He explained that UK Financial Investments, the company set up by the Coalition to manage the taxpayers’ shareholdings in banks, could only “consult” with RBS’s remuneration committee about its views on bonuses.

    “It’s done in the spirit of consultation and before any decision is made, we understand what the expectations of us are and what the direction of travel is.”

    He added: “If we come up with something shareholders don’t like, we would run the risk of a bad vote at the AGM.”

    One banker noted how the RBS board was unequivocal in believing Chancellor George Osborne did not set the bonus of Mr Hester, who was being urged to accept a £1m-plus bonus.

  • dr spyn

    Almost as bad as finding that there is no life in the battery at the crucial moment. 

    Could have been worse – it might have been a car transporter train…

  • tim

    Of course they have the legal right, the Deputy Chairman of the Tory Party is all over the media claiming they intervened to reduce the bonus.

    The Pm has been all over the mediansaying he was going to intervene.

  • Anonymous

    It’s what happens when the right organises stuff, I guess.

  • DavidL

    No I have paid substantial taxes to help fund that absurd building and those pontificating fools who can’t write a comprehensible piece of legislation.

    The costs of such stupidityand self indulgence  really should be borne by those who voted for it.

  • MrsB

    I imagine there is some sort of court of appeal……

  • MrsB

    Why Croatian hookers and not some other nationality?

  • dr spyn

    the court of public opinion?

  • MrsB

    “How many lines are needed to make trainspotting exciting?”

    I assume you are talking about lines of coke?

  • Richard Nabavi

    Are you doubting Sean’s qualifications in this matter?

  • tim

    I’m quite happy for Fallon and Cameron to be charged, but be aware that your accusation of Cameron first making a mistake, then being economical with the truth and now breaking the law
    may bring the wrath of fitalass down upon you.
    Gaddafi’s bodyguards were pussycats by comparison.

  • dr spyn

    It looks as if the organisers think that a yoghurt has more culture…the whole charade is so bloody pathetic.  

  • Anonymous

    RBS is an independent company and the govt have used what pressure they can to encourage the lowest bonus that was realistic.

    I think we can all agree these banks are a mess and we all know why.

  • Anonymous

    “The Bullseye of the dartboard will be a smiling picture of a suitably grateful Nelson Mandela, and when the final, absurdly huge dart hits Nelson’s nose, a weird robotic Mandela-voice will say “me tankyou for abolishing slavery, boss”.”

    Happy Hour already Sean?

  • Richard Nabavi

    To be fair, I think there is a valid criticism that the government has encouraged the view that it can control remuneration rather than just influence it. I also think the government has been too ready to indulge in populist banker-bashing.

  • Anonymous

    As with all opening ceremonies the best thing to do is keep the television switched off.
    For my part I will be doing my best to miss the entire fortnight of this 4-year battle between competing teams of chemists.

  • tim

    I’m a bit disappointed that the Big Society won’t feature, although I’m sure the PB Tories will be cheering the BBC’s coverage of the pawn of praise to the NHS.

  • Anonymous

    So the RBS CEO is on approx 48k a week  much the same as a footballer in a lower placed premier league team..talk about getting priorities right

  • dr spyn

    Each train is operated by a single driver, and comprises up to 234 ore cars, each ore car with a load capacity of approximately 112 tonnes. A fully loaded train weighs approximately 31,000 tonnes and is about 2.4 kilometres in length.
    http://www.riotintoironore.com/ENG/operations/497_rail.asp 

  • antifrank

    Who in their right mind watches an Olympics opening ceremony?

  • Plato

    Now I know it’s not just me that finds Obama tedious listening:

    State of the Union viewers had very short attention spans. More than 1/4 of them tuned out in the first 5 mins: http://t.co/aF2c0VGd

  • http://tomknoxbooks.com SeanT

    Cause the heights of the cultural economy are still commanded by the Left: from the BBC to the National Theatre to, well, wherever… 

    The kind of person who does well in the artistic bureaucracy is nearly always a well-meaning lefty who knows how to say the right words: they are often incompetent, they are generally mediocre, just occasionally they are very talented.

    This normally isn’t a problem – just annoying for us rightwingers, given that our tax money pays their inflated salaries. But no doubt it’s annoying for lefties to bailout incompetent rightwing bankers.

    However it is more than annoying when these same liberal-left dolts are given a global stage and lots of money wherewith to *sell* the UK, and their intense mediocrity means they totally f*ck it up and create a national embarrassment. Yes, I’m talking about the Millennium Dome.

    My fear is the Olympics will be another Dome. My hope is that they have employed some of the few lefties who are actually talented: e.g. Danny Boyle.

  • Anonymous

    You have prompted me to check and its about a third of what was ABN the Dutch took mover.  I think we would have been happy for them to have bought the lot.

  • http://awkwardedmilibandmoments.tumblr.com/ Anoraknophobia

    “I can assure you that the actions of the guys at the top usually have sweet FA to do with the success or otherwise of the firms”

    Ah, the refrain of the overlooked and underappreciated. James Dyson was just lucky, presumably, as was Alan Sugar. All down to his poor, underpaid underlings. You’re hilarious.

  • tim

    Just enjoy the car crash.

    Who do you think Osborne will try to blame, or will he go for the meteorological defence again.

    “he would’ve lent more to SME’s if the weather hadn’t been quite so cold, and share prices always fall in warm weather”

    @paulwaugh
    Really interesting still no Tory minister talking re Hester. Browne, Clegg, Boris, EdM, Fallon and now Tyrie #wheresGeorge?

  • Fluffy Thoughts

    Interesting comment in this week’s The Economist:

    Births in the capital each year have soared by 25% since 2002, as
    British women who delayed childbearing finally got down to it and
    London’s many immigrants produced in Stakhanovite quantities.

    [Src.: http://www.economist.com/node/21543532 ]

    So – along side Defence, Foreign-Affairs and Economics – wee-Timmy knows feck-all about demographics. Better he concentrates on selling boot-leg alcohol to his scouse brethren…!

  • MrsB

    Just his geography.  If he favours Croatian hookers, why is he in Thailand?

  • MrsB

    But I suspect there would be a problem supplying enough coke to fill it….

  • http://tomknoxbooks.com SeanT

    No, I’m relatively sober. I was just trying to think outside the box, and create an Opening Ceremony that would please hypocritical Guardianista Marxists and chavvy BNP voters alike.

    They are all part of the complex and wonderful tapestry of Britishness, and they all deserve to be “celebrated” in a truly inclusive Olympic party. No?

  • tim

    Maybe it would give you and Daria something to talk about.

  • http://www.biologymad.com/ HD2

    BBC claim 1 billion will watch it, antifrank.

    I’d suggest that the number who will see their own nation’s athletes walk in (in News clips) will be nearer 5 billion.

    The number watching the entire ceremony, I grant you, will be in comparison, minimal: just like their IQ…..

  • http://www.biologymad.com/ HD2

    Check the UN building, if you’re short…..

  • http://tomknoxbooks.com SeanT

    That’s a fair point. I’m not sure I’ve watched one ever, and I’m pretty sure I won’t watch the one in London, either.

    In fact I am quite unbelievably apathetic about the whole thing: even the beach volleyball. 

    In years past I used to get excited about Olympic Games, now I couldn’t give the tiniest toss about any of it. Have I finally achieved wisdom or sunk into terminal cynicism? 

    I think it’s wisdom. These days I much prefer world cups – i.e. football, rugby or cricket. Proper sports. English sports! Not greco-roman wrestling or “korfball”.

  • Anonymous

    As I said, the Tories are in full control of what is done at the Olympics. If they want to appoint Danny Boyle to organise things that is up to them. 

  • http://www.biologymad.com/ HD2

    I suspect the fact that we have a NHS is largely unknown around the world, since paying an insurance premium and getting near ‘free-at-the-point-of-use’ treatment is what they are used to.

    Mind you, they get to choose the insurer, and get treated in days, not months, but hey……

  • Anonymous

    I think it’s all the political elite, Southam. They’ve all run with the Blair consensus that everything has to be trendy and cool, and our history doesn’t really matter. That applies to the leadership of all major parties nowadays.

  • Anonymous

    I might put the Ceremony on in the background, like the Royal wedding. Sometimes these types of ceremonies can be worth it for  the comedy value alone, although I would prefer ours be awesome – but the cost and difficulty of that makes it unlikely.

    The Games themselves? Some sports are better than others, but I’ll just watch whatever is on at the time if I’m in the mood and hope GB does well. I

  • Anonymous

    The opening ceremonies are great fun to watch drunk, Sean. You can even play drinking games to get through the tedium of the parade of nations – shot of vodka every time a country comes in you’ve never heard of, or has blue in its flag, or whatever.

    The acrobatics and weird costumes and Soviet-style formation dancing and people dressed as microchips to represent progress, etc – are all quite entertaining if you’re inebriated.

  • Anonymous

    How sad. Our nation has made many mistakes, done many things that in this modern age we would condemn, but there is so much to be proud of, or at least be interested in finding out about rather than dismiss out of hand, but I even have family members who have nothing good to say about the UK, and wish they were American really really badly. Not that Americans aren’t great, but still, bit of a slap in the face to old Blighty, and lots of people are similarly disinterested.

  • http://www.biologymad.com/ HD2

    A friend of mine and his pals, in Ilfracombe, play drinking games for each Olympics.

    100m = 1 pt as fast as possible
    200m = 2pt as fast as possible
    400m, 800m ditto (!)
    Hurdles = pint + a short

    Javelin/discus = throw pint from A to B, catch and drink

    There were loads in all – I’ve only been there once (probably 1982) and can only remember a handful of the events (which were spread over 2 weeks)

  • Kristin

    The sense of frustration amongst the world economic elite at the Eurozone inertia is beginning to crack. International investors are, off the record, confirming to us the remarkable extent of their plans to cope and mitigate a Eurozone collapse.
    This is deeply problematic for those running the Eurozone. The understandable experiment with putting the horse of reining in PIIG debts before the rescue cart is running out of time.
    A leading European bank has begun to account for euros differentially, by nation state. That is to say, they are differentiating a risk to euros that originate in a potentially defaulting country from that of a euro-cert. they, in effect, have invented the concept of a German, Greek and Irish euro.
    http://www.channel4.com/news/chancellor-to-get-new-powers-over-bank-of-england 

  • http://tomknoxbooks.com SeanT

    Derrr. I’m GLAD Danny Boyle is in charge – that’s an inspired rightwing appointment of a talented lefty. Good luck to him. His movies are very good.

    Did you ever go to the Millennium Dome, when it was “the Dome”? Oh god. Oh god oh god oh god. How much did that cost us?

    I went with a left-leaning friend. We both came out gripped with a kind of suicidal despair that so much money had been spent to so little effect: it was a place that made you feel WORSE about everything, your country, yourself, your humanity, your Labour government. 

    It was the triumph of the trite, the apotheosis of the shite, the victory of painful bien piensant pointlessness, and all of it wrapped in a ginormous and ridiculous tent, at a cost of 600 f*cking million quid

    The Dome was New Labour, encapsulated: a great depressing waste of an amazing opportunity, that left us much worse off, with nothing to show for it but sadness. And debt.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Andrea-Parma/578831001 Andrea Parma

    Former Wavertree MP Jane Kennedy has applied for Labour selection for Merseyside Police Commissioner role.

    Some weeks ago Rhodri Morgan has come out in favour of Alun Michael in South Wales.

    When will we know if Prescott will try to get  Humberside candidature?

  • Anonymous

    USA
    Real GDP increased 1.7 percent in 2011 (that is, from the 2010 annual level to the 2011 annual level), compared with an increase of 3.0 percent in 2010.       

    The increase in real GDP in 2011 primarily reflected positive contributions from personal consumption expenditures (PCE), exports, and nonresidential fixed investment that were partly offset by negative contributions from state and local government spending, private inventory investment, and federal government spending.  Imports, which are a subtraction in the calculation of GDP, increased.
    Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/2011-gdp-2012-1#ixzz1kgP5P0uC

  • Anonymous

    I didn’t go because I heard it was crap.

  • Anonymous

    It’s like groundhog day in here….

  • Marquee Mark

    And just how messy was the marathon?

  • Richard Nabavi
  • tim

    6 o clock news not good for the Govt, Boris and Ed saying the same thing, and Osborne claiming the Govt would have had to take over direct running of the bank if they hadn’t paid the bonus (it appears halving the bonus was OK)

    Not a good day for the Fops, Cameron can never posture about fairness again, and Osborne has shot “We’re all in this together” and rammed home the Lord Fauntleroy stereotype.

  • Socrates

    The whole “do you agree” bit causes a bias. “Should Scotland leave the United Kingdom to become an independent state?” seems the most fair to both sides.

  • http://www.biologymad.com/ HD2

    I’m, at best, a slow drinker, whilst Stuart got quicker as each pint of lager passed his lips….

    The marathon, IIRC, was simply the most pints drunk – but I’ve no idea what the time limit was!

    I only watched and timed – it was great fun and there were a dozen or so taking part – some being ‘specialists’ in particular events…..

  • tim

    Skiing?

    No good will come of photos of George and snow, this much we know.

    Shows you how they’ve lost control of the narrative, Fallon is out there claiming the Govt intervened to halve the bonus, Osborne is claiming it wasn’t in their hands.
    Dave says “it wasn’t me guv”

  • http://tomknoxbooks.com SeanT

    It was beyond crap. It was in a whole new world of seventeen–dimensional ultracrap that made mere crap look like the Crown Jewels.

    The Dome was New Labour; New Labour was the Dome. A prolapsed rectum at the butt-end of London, aptly representing the intellectual haemorrhoid that is the British left. 

  • Anonymous

    Poll boost for Miliband & Labour?

    We are giving rich bankers massive bonuses in the same week we are arguing for a cap on benefits.

    It seems we’ll try anything, to save Ed.

  • tim

    Perhaps the Govt should’ve let Aidan Burley do the Olympic choreography.

    Here’s the opening ceremony.

    http://m.eb.com/assembly/2715

  • Socrates

    Having an opening ceremony of the Olympics, the great sporting spectacle that goes back to the glory that was Greece, celebrating a mediocre socialist health system is infinitely more embarassing than the Millenium Dome.

  • tim

    Boris was quick off the mark – he knows that it’s a toxic issue for the Tory leadership, he needs to distance himself.

  • Anonymous

    Can’t remember the last Olympics I gave a sh!t about. Maybe because there were none. Why should I get off when some bloke I’ve never heard of wins a medal in a sport I know nothing about and care less about?

    Back in 1996 I challenged my co-workers on this. Answers from them:
    -it reflects well on the country. Yep. Like East Germany – we all saw those down trodden West Germans wanting to emigrate East because of the medal haul. At least in Goodbye Lenin.
    -we need to spend more money on sports. Yep. So we need to raise taxes so we can get more golds. How many billion a medal would that come to?
    -after 1996 I didn’t bother – less of a sporty office!))

    Consider how many medals the likes of HK, Singapore will get this summer. I know where I’d rather be, instead of in some godforsaken workers’ paradise where people die trying to escape (Cuba) or some leftie’s wet dream (DDR).

  • Socrates

    SeanT has a point here. In many ways, the central focus of London is Trafalgar Square, where we have had a range of art over the last decade on the fourth plinth. They include the God awful lefty art such as these:

    http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2022/2049820710_422c09efdc.jpg
    http://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-images/Arts/Arts_/Pictures/2008/05/28/plinth-copy-7.jpg
    http://www.london.gov.uk/fourthplinth/sites/default/files/FP_445_250_Marc_Quinn.jpg

    Meanwhile, by far the best one, was this:

    http://www.urban75.org/london/images/nelson-ship-in-a-bottle-02.jpg

    Ultimately, what the people want, is the ship that wopped the Frogs.

  • Socrates

    This is a bit odd. Romney converted his militantly atheist father-in-law to the Mormonism after death!

    http://gawker.com/5879888/

  • Anonymous

    Anyone know who will give me a mentally insane contract involving shitloads of money and bonuses if I take over and attempt to save a buggered nationalised bank?

    Just a small side issue though. If the idiots who give me the contract try and go back on it later on (assuning I’ve done what they asked and done my job properly), then I’ll sue their asses and ride off into the sunset with even more cash! I feel damn sorry for any poor buggers who get that sort of deal assigned to them by the w**kers who made it in the first place. I mean, you could even imagine them realising what a stupid deal it was and then trying to pass the buck for their moronic negotiating skills. By the way Tim, you are full of sh*t.

  • Anonymous

    How toxic?  Big poll lead for Labour?

  • tim

    The bonus wasn’t contractual, and the Govt intervened to change the bonus.

    And as for what the Govt asked, well the lending targets weren’t met, and the share price has fallen over the year.

    Besides that, a really good post.

  • RodCrosby

    They ‘convert’ their long-dead ancestors too… Why do you think they are so big on genealogy?

  • Sunil Prasannan

    But the Dome has been turned into a wonderful auditorium – the O2 of course. Saw Depeche Mode there a couple of years ago.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Depeche_Mode_O2_15_12_09.JPG

  • Anonymous

    FPT. ‘Southam is making an interesting point there.  We’ve all been assuming that Salmond really wants DevoMax rather than independence (and indeed he might, for the moment at least).  But it is going to be tricky for the SNP not to campaign whole-heartedly for independence, leaving them with the risk of being seen to be on the losing side if there is a DevoMax option on the ballot (or indeed if there’s not).’

    Salmond
    now appears to be backing away from a DevoMax option on the
    Independence Referendum ballot paper. I suspect Southern is right about
    this though, and that Salmond now intends to make DevoMax the new
    Nationalist aim in their manifesto come the next Scottish Elections to
    try and breath life back into the Independence cause. Just take the
    issue of their stance on a Scottish currency, keeping sterling and the
    BoE as lender of last resort. Sounds far more plausible and reassuring
    if you are trying to sell DevoMax and not full Independence.

    At
    the end of the day, Salmond knew he couldn’t win an Independence
    Referendum in light of the current economic crisis/turmoil facing us
    over the next decade. But Salmond still wants to win the next Scottish
    election while still brandishing a powerful bargaining tool against
    Westminster. And just when its going to be far tougher defending their
    current majority after five years in power in 2016.

    Cameron/Osborne
    played a blinder when he smoked out Salmond over the Independence
    Referendum. They then retired and left Salmond to finally face some real
    media scrutiny with the difficult questions that came with it. And all
    we got was long winded rhetoric short on credible details. Its been like
    Swinney finally launching that Local Income tax policy all over again.
    Sounds nice and appears quite popular until you scrape away at the
    rhetoric and start to see the logistical details underneath it.

    The SNP have boasted about a few Nat voters joining the party over
    recent weeks. Would love to know what their internal polling is showing with regards opinion among the wider Scottish electorate. DevoMax simple wasn’t on the radar of the Scottish
    public until now. And Salmond risked damaging and losing that argument
    too by wrapping it up as a consolation prize for his party in the
    Independence Referendum. Like AV, it was all getting too complex while
    the politics behind it remains all too simple and transparent.

  • Anonymous

    Just joined, haven’t read the thread.

    IMHO, based on the experience of the LibDems and the voting reform referendum, it’s an excellent idea to allow the people with the ardent desire for change, to set things up to give themselves the best possible chance of winning.

  • Anonymous

    Really?   Do you think the Dome is  still costing the taxpayer money? I would be very surprised if it was not.

  • Ishmael_X

    it isn’t that simple; he had a right to have the committee consider whether to give him a bonus and a right to the bonus once they had awarded it and a cracking good claim against the govt in the tort of interfering with a contract if they intervened in the matter.

    It seems to me hester should voluntarily cap his bonus at £26,000. That solves two problems at once and makes it clear to the underclass that we are all in this together.

  • Anonymous

    Lik

  • Anonymous

    Yep, that bank is still losing loads of money right? He takes over when it’s making a humungous loss and now it’s er……making a tidy profit.

    I ain’t defending any bankers, they are all a bunch of overpaid greedy etc etc… But this is hypocritical opportunism of the highest order by your lot. And the bar is set bloody high where Labour is concerned.

  • Anonymous

    Evening all,

    On topic,

    Politician moulds referendum question in self-serving manner. Go figure! Politicians are the last people who should have any say over any part of the voting process. Leave it to the Electoral Commission.

    In other news Government agreements are not worth the paper they are printed on if the Milky Bar Kid (Ed Miliband) gets his way. Of course paying Thompson £800,000 at the BBC and Crozier £1 million to wreck Royal Mail was OK at the time.

  • Socrates

    Converting people that insisted on not converting when they were alive just seems a bit odd. That’s all.

  • Anonymous

    ‘On topic, it’s obvious the SNP have a creeping tendency towards
    vote-rigging.  They’re afraid of asking a question that has been
    independently-vetted to ensure neutrality, they’re seeking to rig
    the
    electorate to maximise their prospects of success, they’ve even sought
    to run away from the referendum being supervised by the body with
    practical skill and experience in the area.  It’s really rather
    disturbing that they don’t seem to want to get a handle on basic good
    practice in running elections.’

    antifrank, I have had growing worries about the behaviour of this SNP administration for a while now. None of this is really any surprise.

  • Anonymous

    What on earth were Brown & Darling thinking about when they negotiated this contract with RBS / Hester,I know they had a soft touch for bankers but what a crazy deal.

    Was the promise of a knighthood also thrown in?

  • Anonymous

    Yeah and don’t forget Goodwin’s golden handshake and his peerage and all the rest.

  • tim

    It would be nice if there was an intelligent PB Tory around to answer your points, but as there doesn’t seem to be.

    The

    Bonus

    Was

    Not

    Contractual.

  • Ishmael_X

    yes
    it
    was
    see
    my
    previous
    post

    And if they had told hester he was getting £100,000, a mercedes and no bonus guess what he would have said to them? so they negotiated a deal which saves their arses and poisons another well for the next govt. lovely blokes.

  • Anonymous

    So lets get this right. There was no bonus offered in the contract at all?  Then why is he getting one?

  • tim

    That is the question we do not know the answer to.
    None of the smoke put up on here, or by the Govt has answered that.

  • Sunil Prasannan

    I suggested 26K on last night’s thread :)

  • Anonymous

    It’s toxic, but will it show up in opinion polls?  Will it matter, or will it be Coulson Mark 2?

  • Anonymous

    This NHS in the Olympics Opening Ceremony is a sickener. It’s a patchy, free-at-the-point-of-rationing/queuing service …. Mind you we do have Europe’s fattest nurses (the practice manager at my local GP surgery is at least 20 stone) whose attitudes towards the clients often leave a lot to be desired. Still, if it’s anything like last August here in Birmingham and London, we could really put on a fireworks display which will fully engage the world’s attention.

  • Sunil Prasannan

    More info regarding the O2 here

  • Anonymous

    But the Labour Government would have been aware of the terms of his employment (and presumably agreed it) so why hasn’t Miliband or Darling (who would definitely know) come out and clarify the situation once and for all instead of Miliband persisting with his monkey spanking politics of envy performance ?

  • Anonymous

    It’s a reminder not to nationalise things.

  • Kristin

    Brown & Darling couldn’t stop bonuses either   - 
     

    http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/money/article2218484.ece Darling seems to this was a contractual problem -Speaking to the BBC yesterday, he said: “Obviously, there are contractual problems with some staff ”

    So why didn’t they do something about it ?

  • Anonymous

    Its a reminder not to let Labour near any sort of financial negotiation!

  • Anonymous

    Perhaps the queues of athletes waiting to get onto the track reminded them of something?

    [edit] Its like saying Come to Britain. Its over-centralised, its oppressively bureaucratic, its dysfunctional, its obese, its wasteful, its dirty and you have to wait forever before you can ‘enjoy’ its delights and if you stay here too long it might well kill you.

  • tim

    Who knows, I think this may be an issue that cuts through, but you haven’t been listening if you expect a single issue to immediately feed into VI figures, remember Daves ratings and the lag before the Tories lost their election winning lead?

    Keep an eye on Daves ratings for things like, in touch, understands people like us, fairness etc.

  • Anonymous

    I think the Tories will take a temporary hit – it’s an embarrassment for the Gov, but one most people would have expected.

  • Plato

    I saw a tweet earlier from someone who’d been polled by ICM for what appeared to be a Scotland only poll.

    And in other news – John Denham thinks English Labour really ought to do something about England… nice they’re finally noticing… The fact that he’s floating the idea at the IPPR think tank speaks volumes.

    http://www.ippr.org/articles/56/8585/the-rise-of-english-pride

  • Anonymous

    If I understand things correctly, the taxpayer is on the hook for about 40 billion quid with RBS. Hester is there to basically get that back. You (Tim on behalf of his bosses at Labour HQ),are just trying to distract the public by going hell bent for leather at the ‘moral unfairness’ of the bonus awarded to the bloke you put there in the first place.

    Just stop it for once. Just bloody once. Face the reality. Part of the way capitalism works involves some people getting shedloads more money than they may bloody deserve. It happens. This is not even a footnote in the 200 volume encyclopedia of feck ups by the last Labour Government. On principle bankers are totally taking the piss, in reality Britain needs the finance industry to contribute big time to the economy.

    You are the propaganda mouthpiece of the attack dept of the Labour party. I’m sure that I’m not the only one on here fed up with with your robotic nonsense.

  • Anonymous

    In 6 months time, Labour to have a constant poll lead based on the salary of a Chief Executive of a bank that Labour effectively nationalized – I think it’s a stretch, but we’ll see…

  • tim

    Michael Fallon has been doing it all day.

    He says the payment was not contractual, but that the Govt stepped in to temper it.

    Osbornes story is that they tempered it, but that had they gone further the Govt would’ve had to take over day to day running of the bank.

    Camerons story is that although he said he would veto seven figure bonuses he wasn’t “directly” involved in this.

  • Kristin

    test