h1

Is David Davis planning a second resignation?

August 2nd, 2011

Could this create the vacancy so Boris could return?

I’m picking up a vibes from Tories in Yorkshire,  where I used to work, that David Davis is thinking about leaving the commons early next year so he can be his party’s candidate in next year’s election for the Police commissioner of Humberside where, of course, he is currently MP for Haltemprice and Howden.

These elections, which have hardly attracted any attention, are set to take place almost all over England next May and will each cover many parliamentary seats and involve huge electorates.

What’s clear is that successful candidates are going to need to have a high level of name recognition in the respective police force areas and my guess that a number of senior MPs, who now see their chances of preferment drifting, might be tempted to chuck their hats into the ring.

And could this open up a Tory by-election vacancy to provide the platform for Boris to return to the commons? I’d be surprised if the Mayor has not thought about it.

As for David Davis he’s no stranger to resigning as MP and forcing a by-election. He stood down in Haltemprice and Howden in 2008 as a protest against what he saw as Labour’s authoritarianism and then got re-elected. In 2005 he was hot odds-on favourite for the Tory leadership only to be beaten by David Cameron.

@MikeSmithsonPB




  • tim

    394 – Go ahead, but we all know your record for being hilariously wrong with election predictions precedes you.

  • TimT

    Seth @ 392 Neither does it apply to the Italian cousins, the Prosciutto di Parma, who hang out very congenially with the Refosco del Penduncolo.

  • Southam Observer

    384 – Integrated in terms of economic activity and infrastructure, certainly not in terms of feeling “Spanish”.

  • Ave it

    oldnat = lol

  • GeoffM

    Southam Observer @402 Right, gotcha. Agreed.

  • Seth O. Logue

    Don’t worry about tim, Yokel. The Tory Majoritarians are a fine club and you, I, Philippe and OGH are worthy members.

    It is one of those rare occasions in life when we can collectively look down on the winners.

  • hunchman

    If the Euro breaks up next year as I suspect, then that will be 2012-1999 = an unlucky 13 year project. How apt for the Eurocracy, hadn’t realised that before.

  • TimT

    hunchman Any idea what percentage of traders/trading computer programmes follow Elliott wave analysis? Is its use widespread or niche?

  • Mick Pork

    400. Be fair. He hasn’t become a complete lunatic and predicted Lansley will be PM. :lol:

  • Philippe Magnan

    TimT — I’ve settled my bet with Pong (with interests) and am in the process of paying tim on our bet on Palin.Running.

    At least.

    I can’t stand life in Canada very well. For instance, we went to a MusicFest a few days ago. The only available food was overpriced j*nk and cool hyper-trendy stalls selling you fake (chemical) ice cappucinos. I really miss the authenticiy of an Asian market.
    Plus everything closes so early; the taxis are ridiculously expensive and the public transport s*cks when you travel with a 1- year-old.
    There are too much reglementations as well. My boy is too young to go (even with me holding him) in the public swimming pool aroudn the corner.
    The food is generally fattening and insipid.
    Not enough young people around: it’s a geriatric society.
    And it’s hard for our kid to go play with others, usually older, in parks. Kids of different age don’t seem to mix very well.
    People have very pre-programmed lifestyle, with little place for the impromptu, the happening — so hardly any event can take place.
    I’m bored, but I’m doing it for the money.
    When I’m sad, I think of the money I’m making, and how quite soon I will be free again (if I’m lucky enough with my speculations).

  • Philippe Magnan

    moderator — can you free my latest post from the spam-trap (my last reply to TimT) ?

  • hunchman

    407 – I’ve heard about 50% according to some market polls, but that was an EW internal poll, so caution advised. And you’d never use it on its own or you can go very wrong with it – use with MACD, RSI, Stochastics, market volume etc. And EW is much better with longer term time frames, rather than the shorter term.

  • Philippe Magnan

    Regarding the Debt Ceiling

    Obama has just notified Congress that the US was within $100B of the debt limit. The $400B is now released, so the debt ceiling is now around $14.7T.

    Congress is now in recess until September.

  • Seth O. Logue

    408 Pork

    Old MacLansley had a farm.
    And oh, that farm was big.
    The only animals he would have
    Was a pig, and a pig, and a pig.

    Old MacLansley had a farm
    And oh, what a farm had he.
    When he counted his livestock,
    He counted, pig one, pig two, pig three.

    Old MacLansley had a farm.
    And oh, that farm was great.
    And when his piggies went to market,
    He ate, and he ate, and he ate.

    The above is posted exclusively for an educational purpose. My source states clearly:

    This site contains expressions and phrases about pigs and hogs that are common in the English language.

    Objectives:

    1. Help students develop comprehension strategies to relate ideas, organize information, and distinguish fact from fantasy.

    2. Help students learn to respond actively and imaginatively to literature.

    3. Help students connect what they learn in school to what they do outside of school.

    Activities:

    4. Have students write their own original song including as much factual information as possible relating to pigs. Other students can read or listen to the song and see if the fact agree with what they have learned. (NOTE: A game format could be made with these songs with students including at least one totally “false” fact about pigs and other students identifying the false information).

  • Yokel

    400. I bet, less than 40% of my bets on horse racing for example w come home winners. Others like boxing come home over half the time and so on. Financial bets are percentage better, politics, probably about 50-50.

    I tend to back relative outsiders so do expect to lose plenty.

    I make a profit overall.

    I succeed overall sometimes lots, sometimes not so lots.

    What is it you do again?

  • oldnat

    Seth O. Logue @413

    Alas your pharmacist is not qualified to deal with your problem. :-(

  • TimT

    hunchman Thanks.

  • tim

    414 – Chill, and cut the lectures about politics, I realise you have your strengths outside that topic.

  • Nick Palmer

    On topic – probably not in view of the vehement denial, but note that Mike didn’t actually link “Davis to stand down” with “Boris to stand in that by-election” – he suggested that other MPs might be tempted in their localities, giving a more tempting opening for Boris than Yorkshire. But the Tories would be very annoyed to have to find a new Mayoral candidate, and I can’t see it.

    Off topic – it’s interesting how DD’s narrowed eyes in the thread header make him look thoughtful and judicious (not the first words that otherwise spring to mind about him). There ought to be a book about how people react to different eye positions (perhaps there is).

  • http://politicalbetting.com johnno

    417/418 tim & nick – you two believe in democracy,so you will be signing then ?

    http://www.express.co.uk/web/referendum

  • TimT

    philippe Know what you mean about Western society being rigid and geriatric. Each time I go to Morocco (or any Middle Eastern country) the youthful vibrancy of society is palpable in its contrast to the West.

    Alas, we also seem unable in the West to simply enjoy what we have – everything seems to be valued in comparison to something or someone else, rather than for its intrinsic ability to make our lives easy and enjoyable.

    Of all the things I miss in the US, (and fortunately these still exist in parts of Europe) the street market with really fresh fruits and vegetables is moving up to number 1.

    Hope you are enjoying your son and making up games for you to both play.

  • Ave it

    418 nick – when are we having another ‘be nice to each other’ thread?!

  • Mick Pork

    413. Poor Log. So predictable yet so amusing.
    When all else fails you always try so very desperately to condescend but that obvious desperation always backfires to reveal a pompous poser blustering furiously.

    You tried a different version of that post already with oldnat (originality not being a strongpoint of yours) and I fear I laughed very hard indeed as he destroyed your pretension.

    Keep at it Log as your efforts never fail to raise a smile. :-)

  • Steve45

    Have labour ever hit 45% on YouGov before?

    Tim what do you think the impact of police chiefs will be on support for right wing parties? Isn’t it sort of like the tories removing one of their USP’s. I mean would the Tories have won a majority If the people of west London could have voted for a labour person running the NHS but with a Tory government for other areas?

  • Philippe Magnan

    420 — ” we also seem unable in the West to simply enjoy what we have ”
    you’re right — I shall become more creative in that regard.

  • tim

    Cameron and credibility on defence.

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/defence/8678317/Cuts-have-left-our-troops-with-mission-impossible-in-Libya-and-Afghanistan.html

    423 – I’d be more concerned that the turnout is low, allowing well organised but narrow campaigns to get unrepresentative placemen elected.

  • oldnat

    Mick Pork @422:

    he destroyed your pretension

     
    You do me too much credit. Seth is an interesting chap, with whom I enjoy debating from time to time. However, given his social and political inheritance, I’m afraid that pretensions are too deeply ingrained in him to be destroyed. :-)

  • Philippe Magnan

    Chris Mass has just posted the graph of the DebtCeiling market:

    http://www.midasoracle.org/2011/08/02/intrade-debt-ceiling/

    I did tip PBers at least twice, to short it — and at least 10 hours, before it crashes.

  • Seth O. Logue

    401 TimT

    Pork has cousins everywhere, but few of aristocratic lineage. We have mentioned the Italians and the Spanish so noblesse oblige requires reference to the Jambon de Bayonne family. They mix with the sweet and sour too: a fine Sauternes or a dry Jurançon.

  • Witan

    Is any newspaper editor worth £605k? Especially the editor of the Guardian, a newspaper losing £54 million a year.

    No wonder they believe in Ballsgnomics.

  • http://politicalbetting.com johnno

    425.Cameron and credibility on defence

    just like labour and all politicians,have you signed yet ?

  • Philippe Magnan

    – tim : the cash in now into your account:

    Dear Philippe,

    We have now transfered your funds as per your request.

    Please let us know if we can help you further.

    Kind regards,

    Sheena Hurley
    Customer Support Team
    Intrade Exchange Operations

  • Richard Nabavi

    tim @425:

    I’d be more concerned that the turnout is low, allowing well organised but narrow campaigns to get unrepresentative placemen elected.

     

    Unlikely that we’ll get people more unrepresentative and more of the placeman type than under the current system.

  • oldnat

    Seth O. Logue @428:

    few of aristocratic lineage

     
    I said your pretensions were ineradicable! No doubt your deference to the aristocracy is based on your identification with the Marquis de Sad. :-(

  • Yokel

    417. The issue is the gross distillation of GOP politics.

    In 2007/2008 we had the similar view of the GOP by some posters who just saw them in caricature the whole way. Then it was the religious right now its the Tea Party. They are factions of greater or lesser degree, and not the whole story.

    Backing against that caricature was a grand success.

    There is a decisive enough split between the evangelicals and the Tea Partiers that suggests they may not vote anywhere near as a contiguous block. A section overlaps, an equally large section does not.

    It is in that difference that you may find the decisive block that swings the primaries. The other potentially decisive block is independents in states where there are open primaries. As yet we have little definition of who they are. Are they genuine swing voters, are there more disillusioned former Republicans amongst their ranks.

    The religious angle is also over-pursued. Whilst the evangelicals were big on GWB they were an engine, not the voters who made all the difference in his ascent to the White House. Yet the evangelicals couldn’t stop McCain who didn’t fit their mold in 2008. Yet plenty of people we define might define as ‘religious right’ in this part of the world, voted for McCain. Too often we see them a unified group and they are far from it.

    Very few people have also noticed that the primary season has been skewed by the GOP herarchy? Why? They don’t want a case of runaway early momentum with early voting states.

  • tim

    431 – Got it, thanks Philippe.

  • Philippe Magnan

    434 — yes, increasingly the Tea Party is becoming a movement against Spending, For fiscal responsability. It does not move along lines of religion or ethnicity or “class”.

  • LondonStatto

    Philippe Magnan @436:

    increasingly the Tea Party is becoming a movement against Spending

     

    Isn’t that how it started?

  • oldnat

    Philippe Magnan @436:

    the Tea Party is becoming a movement against Spending

     
    And does that include spending for the benefit of the military–industrial complex that Eisenhower warned against? I suspect not.

  • Richard Nabavi

    Peter the Punter @263:

    we have to be careful not to see it through European eyes.

     

    Yes, I am extremely conscious of that danger. Usually I try to look at what US commentators are saying, rather than form my own view directly. Having said that, I have travelled a lot in the US, and have worked with a lot of Americans from various states (though not a representative sample, of course), so I think I do at least understand some of the pitfalls of taking a European view.

    In the case of Rick Perry, the US commentators were giving contradictory signals, so I decided to see for myself what the fuss was all about.

    But he was just boring. Sure, he ticked a few boxes to get the activists cheering, but given that the whole point was supposed to be that Perry would inspire, in contrast to dullards like Romney and T Paw, I was expecting something a little inspirational.

    Given two boring front-runners, one of whom has done this before, has a big funding advantage, and is unlikely to make a big gaffe, I tend to favour (in a betting sense) the dull-and-safe over the dull-but-risky.

  • Seth O. Logue

    433 oldnat

    No doubt your deference to the aristocracy is based on your identification with the Marquis de Sad.

    My great role model is the Marquis de Parys. His bedroom manners are reputed to be better.

    As to my pretensions being too deeply ingrained to be destroyed, I should warn you that I keep them in the safe and shake hands in public with a common touch.

  • Philippe Magnan

    437 — yes indeed. My only point was that the Tea Party, as a movement, does not follow other ligns of force, such as ethnicity, religion, economical status, etc.

  • Philippe Magnan

    – and it is increasingly obvious.

  • Seth O. Logue

    Philippe Magnan @431:

    tim : the cash in now into your account:

     

    Did tim win that bet or are you settling as a welfare benefit?

    My apologies for intruding into the privacy of contract but we do need to keep tabs on the company with whom we are keeping on pb.

  • oldnat

    Seth O. Logue @440:

    Marquis de Parys

     
    You need to be careful in suggesting on here that you model yourself on a purebred Arabian. Many calls have probably been made to the security services suggesting that you shouls be investigated as a potential Islamist activist.

  • Philippe Magnan

    443 — To show PB my good faith. And to compensate for the stress he might have incurred from my recent irresponsive behaviour toward Pong — as he had a bet with me that looked everyday more like a winner.

  • oldnat

    Philippe Magnan @441:

    the Tea Party, as a movement, does not follow other ligns of force, such as ethnicity, religion, economical status, etc.

     
    But its attitude to military America?

  • Yokel

    “I was closer than most people think to jumping in, Pat. But when it got down to it I felt like the atmosphere right now was so toxic. And part of it is that I think many people in my party, the Republican party, are unrealistic and what they want is something that no one can deliver. And that is a candidate who is going to solve every problem in an election cycle.”

    The GOP primary candidate problem by some guy called Mike Huckabee.

  • tim

    445 – If Palin does stand, I’ll donate half this to the site.
    As it is I extended my position £100 further than I wouldve done as I presumed you had f£cked off.

  • Philippe Magnan

    I’m a big fan of le Marquis de Sade.

    Have you read “Juliette”? It’s kind of the last chapter of Don Quixote, the first one of modernity…
    Le Marquis was virtually the first one in Western litterature to calls *things* by their actual name, thus killing the huge space occupied by classical rhetoric. By naming everything, le Marquis opened the way to infinite violence, life and death, desire, and sexuality in Art and Philosophy…

  • Philippe Magnan

    446 – i dunno, honestly.

  • Sea Shanty Irish

    tim & Philippe – slainte!

  • Mick Pork

    441. Perry and Romney have an interesting history in an article I posted if the moderator would be kind enough to release it from moderation.

    There is no love lost there it seems.

  • Seth O. Logue

    Arabs are wonderful horses oldnat. Well done on finding the Marquis de Parys! A perfect cousin for the thoroughbred Mister Smithson!

  • oldnat

    Philippe Magnan @449:

    I’m a big fan of le Marquis de Sade.

     
    Perhaps. But I didn’t include the final “e” when chiding Seth.

  • oldnat

    Seth O. Logue @453:

    Well done on finding the Marquis de Parys!

     
    A great thing, a search engine!

  • Seth O. Logue

    Philippe Magnan @445

    I knew Philippe! And welcome back. My purpose in asking was purely to disarm tim’s bragging rights.

  • Seth O. Logue

    454 oldnat

    But I didn’t include the final “e” when chiding Seth.

    I had noticed. I put it down to Scotland not undergoing the middle English great bowel shift.

  • oldnat

    Seth O. Logue @457:

    the middle English great bowel shift.

     
    But I see you still use the Southern English intrusive “f”.

  • tim

    456 – I’ve been laying Palin in every Market available for nearly two years now, it’ll take more than you to disarm my weapon.

  • Seth O. Logue

    Philippe Magnan @449:

    I’m a big fan of le Marquis de Sade.

     

    He certainly pushed the boundaries of literary imagination. But in the end it was buggering a maid that did for him.

    So much for the French Revolution. Some things never change in France.

  • Philippe Magnan

    @ SSI

    I have a few good quotes for you in store for you about past American presidents and pokah. For another day.

    What do you think of Perry’s chances?

  • Philippe Magnan

    – 459 Wow!

  • Philippe Magnan

    We will win our Palin Shorts unless SSI or another neo-Merry Prankster drops some LSD in her drink, and then she goes nuts, and claim she’ll run on Hannity.

  • Philippe Magnan

    “He certainly pushed the boundaries of literary imagination. But in the end it was buggering a maid that did for him.”

    I’d rather say : he destroys the classical boundaries set by Cervantes, and replaced ‘imagination’ with litteral anatomy. By being the first pornster, he opened the way to modernity in litterature!

  • tim
  • Seth O. Logue

    oldnat @458:

    But I see you still use the Southern English intrusive “f”.

     

    My very first linguistics tutorial was on the final inflected -e in Middle English. Well the real purpose of the lesson was to demonstrate that imported or invented words get adopted into a language and become subject to its laws including changes.

    I was told the word “pipe” was originally created as an onomatopoeia pronounced ‘pee-per’ to imitate the sound made when sucking on a pipe. But that the great vowel shift lengthened the “i” to ‘ai’ and it lost its final inflectional ‘e’. So ‘pee-per’ became ‘paip’.

    Now I thought Sir Walter Raleigh introduce tobacco from the colonies in the early 17th century. So just what was it that those middle-English mediaevals were smoking?

  • Philippe Magnan
  • Philippe Magnan

    I just bought 23 shares of S&P.DOWNGRADE.US.DEC13 @ 51.2%

  • TimT

    old nat The Tea Party does not seem to have a monolithic view on military spending. The most fiscally conservative and libertarian amongst them are isolationist and so would cut military spending and bring home the troops. Then there are some who are not isolationist, but recognise that military spending has to take its hit too. Finally, there are some, and I don’t know the percentage, who would protect military spending.

  • oldnat
  • oldnat

    Seth O. Logue @466:

    So just what was it that those middle-English mediaevals were smoking?

     
    When I look at the Governments selected by Middle England, one could ask the same question now!

    (Enjoyed your description of your linguistics teaching though. My English tutor could be extremely inventive too – especially when the tutorials were held in the pub.)

  • Seth O. Logue

    Philippe Magnan @464:

    By being the first pornster, he opened the way to modernity in litterature!

     

    Not sure you can get away with that claim, Philippe.

    Mediaeval and ancient classical literature had their fair share of ‘pornographers’.

    In modern times John Wilmot, The 2nd Earl of Rochester, established new boundaries for English literature in the late 17th century restoration (see ‘A Ramble in St James Park’ at http://bit.ly/ntckLk ).

    What the Marquis de Sade did was to move the imaginative and literal onto the field of the illegal and taboo.

  • fitalass

    Yokel @434

    Yokel, that is an excellent post and I think you really do make the underlying point here that keeps getting missed. It certainly fits with the discussions I have had with my American relatives over the last year.

  • fitalass

    Yokel @447:

    “I was closer than most people think to jumping in, Pat. But when it got down to it I felt like the atmosphere right now was so toxic. And part of it is that I think many people in my party, the Republican party, are unrealistic and what they want is something that no one can deliver. And that is a candidate who is going to solve every problem in an election cycle.”

    The GOP primary candidate problem by some guy called Mike Huckabee.

    Wow!! Some very plain talking from Mike Huckabee. But then when you look at the far more interesting array of possible Republican candidates who decided to miss this one out. You get the feeling that its maybe not just about going up against Obama, but that the whole election this time around might turn out to be a poisoned chalice for any party who wins?  

  • oldnat

    fitalass @474:

    the whole election this time around might turn out to be a poisoned chalice for any party who wins?

     
    That was also said of the UK GE in 2010 and the Scottish GE in 2011. It doesn’t seem to stop politicians campaigning to win though! :-)

  • corporeal

    475. A bird in the hand…

  • Seth O. Logue

    476 … is worth two under Bush.

  • fitalass

    oldnat @475

    oldnat, its going to be interesting to watch events in the US and in Europe over the next few months and years. Spain up next, and after the terrible events that dominated their last election, its going to be equally febrile this time around due to their economy.

  • notme

    476. Government is always hard, the 1997 to 2005 period will probably be seen as one of the most economically benign periods in our history, yet Blair wouldnt shut up about ‘hard choices’. The reality is, government is usually crisis management, one screw up after another.

    Having sustained economic growth, bursting at the seams revenues and low inflation is not the normal course of events.

    From 1945, when the Labour Government sent us on one path, it was crisis management, to 1979 when the Conservatives set us on another. We only got stability following our exit from the ERM.

    From 1992 to 2008 we had sustained prosperity (though we find the growth of the last few years of that period was entirely illusionary and built on credit, both government, banking and consumer)

  • Philippe Magnan

    Seth : “Mediaeval and ancient classical literature had their fair share of ‘pornographers’.”

    They didn’t name things, they used analogy.

    Sade however catalogued perverted passions in details, descripting almost every possibilities. Like a grammatician of perversion, the characters of his books are trying to name the violence immanent to sexuality, death and desire.

    I agree however that the notion of “being the first” is very fragile, tenuous.

  • oldnat

    Philippe Magnan @480:

    They didn’t name things, they used analogy.

     
    Surely that was only true of “patrician” literature. “Demotic” literature was quite straightforward in its use of language.

  • Seth O. Logue

    Philippe Magnan @480:

    They didn’t name things, they used analogy.

     
    Part of the problem of tracing literary antecedents for eroticism is that each age applies its own ethical standards to the source. Careful translation and cautious editing can obscure original meaning. There is also a tendency to assign to the original author and text a contemporary purpose and sensibility. So what might have just been a ‘dirty poem with dirty language’ becomes an allegory to the Victorian interpreter.

    Just look at how the Church has interpreted, translated and edited the Song of Songs in the Old Testament over the centuries. Pope Benedict XVI is the latest with his encyclical ‘Deus Caritas Est (God is Love)’ of 2006 refers to Song of Songs in both its literal and allegorical meaning, stating that erotic love (eros) and self-donating love (agape) is shown there as the two halves of true love, which is both giving and receiving.

    More disinterested scholars than those of the Vatican will seek to trace parts of the song to the Mesopotamian and Sumerian traditions of erotic poetry, particularly ‘bridal songs’ where the original texts are unambiguously direct and literal in the actions and parts described.

    If we think how many words and euphemisms we have for male and female genitalia today, then compound that through many millennia, languages and civilisations the problems of being ‘lost in translation’ are clear.

    As SeanT admitted the other night, it has taken him a full six years to run out of synonyms for “pizzle”.